Reference Guide

Implementation Science Reference Architecture for PHC and Immunization

A system for choosing and combining implementation science theories, models and frameworks in Nigeria's primary health care and immunization programmes. Three backbone questions organise it. Four parts classify every approach: what kind of tool it is, which part of the system it addresses, which implementation function it serves, and where, when, why and for whom it applies.

Start here if you have a problem to solve. The Implementation Planner walks you from an implementation problem to its determinants, matched strategies and an evaluation plan, using the frameworks below.
Open the Implementation Planner

The Backbone: Three Questions

The whole architecture serves three questions. Ask them in order, then loop back as the work changes.

1Understanding implementationWhat determines whether an interventionis adopted, delivered and sustained?CFIR · TDF · NPT · EPIS · COM-B · BeSDand related theories2Improving implementationWhat strategies address the identifieddeterminants?ERIC · Implementation Mapping · BCWRED · TIP · quality improvement3Assessing implementationIs implementation feasible, appropriate,acceptable, equitable and sustainable?Proctor · RE-AIM · FRAME-ISprocess evaluation approacheslearn and loop back
The three backbone questions. Determinant frameworks and theories answer the first, strategy tools the second, outcome and process evaluation frameworks the third. Findings from assessment feed the next round of understanding.

Keep two kinds of result apart. Implementation outcomes describe how well delivery went: feasibility, appropriateness, acceptability and sustainability. Equity asks whether delivery reached every group fairly. Proctor and colleagues (2011) class equity as a service outcome. Effectiveness describes whether the intervention itself worked, such as fewer zero-dose children. Measure and report each one separately.

Browse the inventory by question: Understanding, Improving or Assessing.

Priority 15 for PHC and Immunization Training

Fifteen approaches deserve particular attention in training. The orientation course introduces all fifteen. The inventory flags them.

No.FrameworkWhy prioritise itBackbone question
1CFIRMultilevel determinantsUnderstanding
2TDFBehavioural determinantsUnderstanding
3EPISImplementation phasesUnderstanding
4i-PARIHSFacilitation and evidence implementationUnderstanding
5NPTEmbedding practices in routine careUnderstanding
6COM-BBehaviour diagnosisUnderstanding
7Behaviour Change WheelIntervention designImproving
8ERICImplementation strategy selectionImproving
9RE-AIMImplementation evaluationAssessing
10Proctor's Outcomes FrameworkImplementation outcomesAssessing
11PRISMContext and implementation outcomesAssessing
12FRAME-ISStrategy adaptationAssessing
13WHO REDDistrict-level immunization implementationImproving
14WHO BeSDVaccination demand determinantsUnderstanding
15WHO TIP/HCD-TIPTailoring immunization programmesImproving

Four Parts of the Classification

Within the backbone, the architecture classifies every tool in four parts. Open a part to see its categories and frameworks.

A. Functional classificationWhat kind of tool is it?Process models · determinant frameworks ·classic theories · implementation theories ·evaluation frameworksB. Seven sector domainsWhich part of the system?1Governance, policy, leadership2Service delivery and integration3Workforce and provider behaviour4Financing, infrastructure, commodities5Information, evidence use, learning6Community and demand7Equity, access, heterogeneous settingsC. Cross-cutting dimensionsWhich implementation function?Strategy selection and specification ·adaptation · fidelity · QI · scale-up ·sustainability · outcomes · complexity andsystems · learningD. Application dimensionsWhere, when, why and for whom?Level · phase · research purpose ·programme area · intended usersFramework inventory: one profile each
The four-part reference architecture. Every inventory entry carries a primary functional category (A), principal and secondary domains (B), any cross-cutting dimensions (C) and its application dimensions (D).

Four Ways In

  1. You know the immunization problem. Use the Selection Guide for first-choice and complementary approaches, or plan it end to end in the Implementation Planner.
  2. You know the system area. Start with a domain, such as community demand or workforce behaviour, then open the frameworks listed.
  3. You know your question. Start with the research purpose table, or follow a problem pathway for common immunization problems.
  4. You know the framework. Search the framework inventory by name, construct or keyword, and filter by any dimension.

Methodological Rules

Eight rules govern every entry: one primary functional category, any number of applications, one principal domain, stated theoretical provenance, framework type, evidence of application, practical utility, and limitations. Related tools are not interchangeable: COM-B is a behavioural model, the Behaviour Change Wheel is an intervention design framework, and the TDF is a synthesis of behavioural determinants. Read the rules and the profile template.

Verification status. Each inventory profile shows one of three statuses: source-verified, standard-reference (verify before citing), or catalogue entry (classification only). Catalogue entries hold their place in the architecture until a verified profile replaces them.